If you have not yet read the Hunger Games books and plan to, stop reading now, because there be spoilers ahead (in abundance). If you don't plan to read them, you probably will also want to stop reading, because you will be very, very bored with this post.
Oh but first, if you liked the Hunger Games books and haven't read "
Ready Player One" (affiliate link) by Ernest Cline, go get it right now. Especially if you are a child of the '80s, because the whole plot centers around '80s trivia (specifically, '80s gaming trivia, but even if you're not a gamer you'll still enjoy it).
Overall, I did like the Hunger Games books. I definitely liked them better than I thought I would. But even though I did find them enjoyable in the long run, I had a lot of problems with them.
Before I get into the issues I had after reading them, first let me tell you why I resisted reading them for so long. First, I don't tend to care for YA fiction to begin with, and "Twilight" really soured me on it. So many of my "Twilight"-fan friends told me I should read "Hunger Games", so I automatically assumed they would be about on par with "Twilight" -- no character development, no real plot to speak of, that sort of thing. (Apologies to the "Twilight" fans in my audience, but I really couldn't stand those books.)
Next, I don't like post-apocalyptic stories, really, so that was a second strike against the books.
Third, I read the sample for the Kindle, which is the first chapter, and found myself not really caring what happened, so I didn't think it would be worth my time to read further.
Kevin read it, and told me it got better. Everyone told me it got better. So this weekend I finally read it, and they were all right. It did get better ... halfway through the book.
I get very bored when there is no dialogue, and most of the first half of Book 1 is just Katniss's inner monologue. But once she teamed up with Rue, it got a little better, and once she teamed up with Peeta (whom I loved -- those of you who are Team Gale are going to have to explain that to me, because I found Gale annoying, though I will admit the actor who plays him in the movie is lightyears hotter than the kid who plays Peeta) I started to actually get invested in the story.
I felt the same way about the second book -- the first half was sort of throwaway to me, but the second half was pretty exciting. I understand why she had to include the two boring first-halves, but I really wish she could've just combined the second two halves of the books into one.
The third book, I hated. I mean, I devoured it, because I needed to find out if they got Peeta back, if they fixed him, if he got the girl in the end. But I didn't care at all about the rebellion and that whole thing. You know, the entire plot of the book.
I also didn't really like Katniss. I found her to be sort of flat and annoying -- I kept waiting for her to get less surly, but the only time she did that was when she was pretending to be in love with Peeta for the cameras, and that bothered me because she seemed to be playacting that very well (which, I know, deep down she wasn't playacting, but she THOUGHT she was, so that's why this bothers me) considering she doesn't seem to be very adept at hiding her thoughts and feelings the rest of the time.
I was mad that the author killed Cinna. I was madder that she killed Finnick -- I LOVED Finnick, and I loved that she let him marry Annie, and I HATED that she then killed him off and then mentioned later that oh, yeah, Annie had his baby after he died. I can't stand stories where women lose the loves of their lives before their babies come, because a parent not getting to meet his child, a parent having to raise a child alone, the whole idea of looking at this baby that is the last link between you and your true love and the agony of missing him that must cause, I just hate it.
I was PISSED that Collin's killed off Prim in the end, because it meant that the entire series had been for nought -- the whole premise of these books is Katniss taking her sister's place to save her life, and to have her sister die off in the very end anyway is just so ... I just felt so let down by the author, you know?
I also really did not care for the epilogue. Generally, I don't like prologues and epilogues, because I feel it's important to start the story at the beginning and end it at the end, and I feel like the 'logues are cheating. But I do understand that sometimes the inciting incident happens when, say, the protagonist is a child, and then she spends the next 10 years getting to a place where she can battle those demons, and that 10 years isn't really that interesting or part of the bulk of the story. A truly gifted author can tell the story starting 10 years later and work the backstory from the prologue into the narrative in a way that works, but this is hard to do smoothly without seeming like he's saying, "Oh, by the way, when Janet was seven her whole family was killed in front of her eyes and that's why she's the way she is and why her goal is to become a soldier and get revenge," which is such a lame way of getting that part of the story across. So I get why authors do it, but it usually annoys me a little.
Epilogues, though, almost always bug me, and I need to just not read them, but if there are more words to read I HAVE to keep going, especially because I always hope the author won't let me down. But epilogues are so often just saying, "and then they got married and had babies", and I really didn't need to know that Katniss and Peeta (whose couple name on the internet is, apparently, "Peeniss", which will never cease to amuse the 12-year-old boy in my head) got married and had babies. It's understood at the end of the book that they end up together -- you know she can't pick Gale because of his possible role in Prim's death, so of course she's going to pick Peeta. You know she loves him, it's been set up all along for her to end up with him (and thank goodness Collins didn't screw that one up, or I'd be even madder than I was about Prim, because you don't spend three books having the hero defending the heroine and saving her life and declaring his love, and making it clear that she also has feelings for him even if she's not admitting it, just to say "and then she married someone else"), so OF COURSE she was going to end up with Peeta. So why the epilogue? And the babies? I didn't care if they had babies. I didn't understand why Katniss was so against having the children that Peeta so badly wanted even after the Hunger Games were done for good. I didn't like the whole "they're playing on a graveyard" line. You want a book that basically has a happy ending to end happily, and to end it with that just clouds the whole thing. Which, again, I get the point of it, that in that world it was going to take generations for the despair and agony of the Capitol's reign to go away, but still. Just end it with Snow dying and Coin dying and Katniss and Peeta reconciling, and we all know where the rest of the road leads without you telling us, MS. COLLINS.
My final complaint is this -- that last Games? With the Capitol children? That Peeta was so against, and Katniss said "yes, let's do one last Games, for Prim"? Sickens me. And also proves that Katniss's character arc moved backward instead of forward. The Katniss of the first book would never have voted to kill off 24 more innocent children if she could have stopped it. I understand that her sister's death took a huge toll on her, but for her to say, "Yes, let's do one more for revenge" just makes me dislike her even more. Making the Capitol kids fight to the death in the arena isn't avenging Prim's death, it's just adding to Katniss's own body count, which you'd think would bother her given how much time she's spent talking about all the innocents dying because of her, but obviously it doesn't. And I don't like that Peeta was able to overlook that. Peeta is a good person, and for him to still love her even after she does that knocks him down a peg in my book. Because by him forgiving her that act, he's condoning it the same as if he'd voted for it.
All that said, I did enjoy the series overall. Any book that I devour that quickly does get a thumbs-up from me, even if I do have a lot of complaints about it.
So. Now that you've read my diatribe, what did you think of the books?